According to Jim: 5x13
Renewing Vows
Ruby and Gracie want to get their ears pierced but Cheryl believes that this will lead to the girls growing up too quickly and convinces Jim. Jim and Cheryl renew their wedding vows and Jim walks down the aisle with an earring.
5 - 1Foul Ball Sep. 20, 2005
5 - 2The Tale of the Tape (1) Sep. 27, 2005
5 - 3The Tale of the Tape (2) Sep. 27, 2005
5 - 4Charity Begins at Hef's Oct. 04, 2005
5 - 5The Race Oct. 11, 2005
5 - 6Anec-Dont's Oct. 18, 2005
5 - 7The Chick Whisperer Nov. 01, 2005
5 - 8James & the Annoying Peach Nov. 08, 2005
5 - 9The Dream Nov. 15, 2005
5 - 10Lean On Me Nov. 29, 2005
5 - 11The Gift of the Maggie Dec. 13, 2005
5 - 12Sex Ed Fred Jan. 10, 2006
5 - 13Renewing Vows Jan. 24, 2006
5 - 14The Stick Feb. 07, 2006
5 - 15Mr. Right Feb. 07, 2006
5 - 16Get Your Freak On Feb. 21, 2006
5 - 17The Grumpy Guy Feb. 28, 2006
5 - 18Polite Jim Mar. 07, 2006
5 - 19Daddy Dearest Mar. 07, 2006
5 - 20The Thin Green Line Mar. 14, 2006
5 - 21Jim's Best Friend Mar. 21, 2006
5 - 22Belaboring the Point May. 02, 2006